A Column from the Desk of Assemblyman Karl Brabenec (R,C-Deerpark)
There’s a slogan within certain political circles advocating for a policy known as “Defund the Police.” This policy seeks to move resources away from law enforcement agencies and towards various social programs. While this proposal has garnered attention and sparked a vigorous debate, particularly in Albany, it’s crucial to approach this matter in a manner that respects and acknowledges the dedicated efforts of our law enforcement professionals who operate under challenging conditions and deserve fair compensation and resources. As the son of a former NYPD officer, I have a firsthand appreciation for the sacrifices and unwavering commitment exhibited by these individuals.
It’s equally important to steer this conversation away from extremist viewpoints and strive for a more balanced approach to prioritizing public safety. Recognizing this need, I have introduced a bill, A.5531, titled the “Defend Municipalities that Defund the Police Act.” The primary objective of this legislation is to withhold state funding from localities that choose to “defund the police.” This legislation is founded upon the principle that while communities should possess the autonomy to govern themselves and allocate resources according to their needs, they shouldn’t expect state financial assistance when they significantly shift their funding priorities away from law enforcement. The reduction in state funds would correspond to the reduction in local law enforcement support, forcing these municipalities to choose between pandering to an extremist viewpoint or continuing the basic government operations.
One argument raised in Albany against this approach is that it may appear punitive. However, it’s important to note that the initial call for reducing law enforcement resources arose from concerns about the actions of a few isolated incidents. Most law enforcement professionals do not conform to the negative stereotypes ascribed to them by their critics. They are not reckless thrill-seekers, as some radicals might suggest, but rather they serve as the guardians of our communities, often risking their lives to maintain safer neighborhoods throughout the state.
Addressing any perceived shortcomings within the policing system should never involve defunding but instead rallying behind those who have displayed unwavering valor within its ranks. Let us be unequivocal: law enforcement is totally necessary. Mere budget cuts do nothing to tackle underlying issues. Our society undeniably depends on the men and women in blue who protect us day and night. Toying with their resources isn’t just unfair; it could be deadly. Instead, let’s firmly stand by our law enforcement heroes. This is the right path to addressing concerns and guaranteeing a safer future for our communities.
###
Assemblyman Brabenec represents the 98th District, which includes the city of Port Jervis, the towns of Deerpark, Greenville, Mount Hope, Wawayanda, Minisink, Warwick, Tuxedo, and portions of the towns of Goshen, Monroe, and Ramapo. For more information, please visit his Official Website at www.yourfavoriteassemblyman.com.
